Frequently Asked Questions
Receivership
What is a receiver?
Under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, a “receiver” includes a person appointed by the court under s. 243(1) and, in some circumstances, a person who takes possession or control of all or substantially all of an insolvent person’s business property under a security agreement or another qualifying court order.
What is a court-appointed receiver in Ontario?
A court-appointed receiver is a receiver appointed by the court, usually on the application of a secured creditor, where the court considers it “just or convenient” to do so. At the Ontario level, the court also has interlocutory power under s. 101 of the Courts of Justice Act to appoint a receiver or receiver and manager where it appears just or convenient.
Is every receivership court-appointed?
No. The BIA definition of “receiver” is broad enough to include certain receivers acting under a security agreement as well as court-appointed receivers. That said, many of the most important Ontario litigation questions arise in court-appointed receiverships.
Who can ask the court to appoint a receiver?
Under BIA s. 243(1), a secured creditor may apply to the court for the appointment of a receiver. In Ontario, Rule 41.02 of the Rules of Civil Procedure also provides that appointment of a receiver under CJA s. 101 may be obtained by motion to a judge in a pending or intended proceeding.
What test does the court apply on a receiver appointment motion?
The governing statutory language is whether appointment is “just or convenient.” Under the BIA, the court may appoint a receiver if it considers that just or convenient; Ontario’s CJA s. 101(1) uses the same formulation for interlocutory appointment.
Is 10 days’ notice required before a receiver is appointed?
Often, yes. Where a secured creditor intends to enforce security on all or substantially all of an insolvent person’s inventory, accounts receivable, or other business property, BIA s. 244(1) requires notice, and s. 244(2) generally prohibits enforcement until 10 days after the notice is sent. Under s. 243(1.1), the court generally may not appoint a receiver before that 10-day period expires unless the debtor consents to earlier enforcement or the court considers earlier appointment appropriate.
Can the court appoint a receiver before the 10-day period expires?
Yes. The BIA expressly allows earlier appointment if the insolvent person consents to earlier enforcement after notice, or if the court considers earlier appointment appropriate.
What property can a court-appointed receiver take control of?
Under BIA s. 243(1), the court may authorize a receiver to take possession of all or substantially all of the debtor’s inventory, accounts receivable, or other business property used in relation to the business, to exercise control over that property and the business, and to take any other action the court considers advisable.
Can a receiver also run the business?
Yes, if the order provides for that. Under Rule 41.03(c), an Ontario order appointing a receiver must state whether the receiver is also appointed as manager and, if necessary, define the scope of the receiver’s managerial powers.
Does the appointing order really matter?
Very much. Under Rule 41.03, the order must identify the appointee, address any required security, state whether the receiver is also manager, define managerial scope if needed, and contain whatever directions and terms are just. In practice, the order is central to what the receiver may and may not do.
Must the receiver be a licensed insolvency trustee?
For appointments under BIA s. 243(1), and for certain receivers under the Part XI definition, the Act says that only a trustee may be appointed.
Does a receiver have to prepare reports and accounts?
Yes. Under BIA s. 246(1), a receiver must prepare an initial statement after taking possession or control, and under s. 246(3), on completion of its duties it must prepare a final report and statement of accounts and provide them to the Superintendent and, on request, to creditors within the statutory window.
Who can challenge a receiver’s conduct?
Under BIA s. 248(1), the Superintendent, the insolvent person, the trustee (if there is a bankrupt), the receiver, or a creditor may apply to court if the secured creditor, receiver, or insolvent person is failing or has failed to carry out duties imposed by ss. 244–247.
Who can challenge a receiver’s fees?
Under BIA s. 248(2), the Superintendent, the insolvent person, the trustee (if there is a bankrupt), or a creditor may apply to have the receiver’s statement of accounts reviewed and the fees adjusted. The application must be brought within six months after the statement of accounts was provided to the Superintendent under s. 246(3)
Can the court stop a receiver from proceeding with a realization or sale?
Yes. Under BIA s. 248(1)(b), the court may restrain the secured creditor or receiver from realizing on or otherwise dealing with the property until the relevant duty has been carried out.
Can a receiver ask the court for directions?
Yes. Under BIA s. 249, a receiver may apply to the court for directions in relation to any provision of Part XI of the Act, and Rule 41.05 also allows a receiver to obtain directions by motion unless the conduct of the receivership has been referred.
What happens if a court direction conflicts with the security agreement or the appointing order?
Under BIA s. 250, an order under s. 248 or a direction under s. 249 prevails over inconsistent terms in the security agreement, the appointing order, or another order of the appointing court, to the extent of the inconsistency.
How does a receiver get paid?
If a receiver is appointed under BIA s. 243(1), the court may make orders respecting the receiver’s fees and disbursements, including granting a charge ranking ahead of some or all secured creditors, but only if materially affected secured creditors were given reasonable notice and an opportunity to make representations.
Is a receiver automatically discharged when the work is done?
No. Under Rule 41.06, a receiver may be discharged only by order of a judge.
Can the conduct of the receivership be referred to someone else?
Yes. Under Rule 41.04, an order appointing a receiver may refer the conduct of all or part of the receivership in accordance with Rule 54.
Is receivership the same thing as bankruptcy?
No. The BIA treats secured creditors and receivers in Part XI, while bankruptcy is dealt with elsewhere in the statute. A receivership may occur without a bankruptcy, and a bankruptcy may raise different issues from a receivership.
Does receivership create wage-priority issues?
Yes. In a receivership, BIA s. 81.4 creates a security for certain unpaid wages on current assets in the receiver’s possession or control, subject to the statute’s terms and limits.
Is Soundair still important in Ontario receivership practice?
Yes. The Ontario Superior Court’s Commercial List Authorities Book still lists Royal Bank v. Soundair Corp. under Receiverships, which confirms it remains a standard authority in Ontario commercial receivership practice.
Where are major Ontario receivership matters often heard?
Major Toronto commercial receivership matters are often heard on the Commercial List, which the Superior Court describes as a specialized list established in 1991 and staffed by judges experienced in managing complex commercial litigation.
What duties does a receiver owe?
Under BIA s. 247, a receiver must act honestly and in good faith and must deal with the property of the insolvent person or bankrupt in a commercially reasonable manner.
What we do
Our Services
+ Receivership, Insolvency and Bankruptcy LitigationReceivership, Insolvency and Bankruptcy Litigation
Let us solve your legal issue
- intake@melaw.ca
- (416) 923-0003
Years
Experience
Successful
Cases
Main Areas of
Specialization
Dedication to
Your Case
Reach out to us today
- We will review your case
- Evaluate your options
- Provide tailored solutions
- Develop a strategic plan
- Protect your business interests