A unanimous shareholder agreement in Ontario is a written agreement that can restrict some or all of the directors’ powers to manage or supervise the corporation. It matters because those restrictions can transfer significant governance powers, duties, and liabilities from directors to the shareholders exercising them.
How Is a Unanimous Shareholder Agreement Different From an Ordinary Shareholders’ Agreement?
Under OBCA s. 108(1), shareholders may enter into a written agreement governing how they exercise their voting rights.
A unanimous shareholder agreement, or USA, goes further.
Under s. 108(2), a written agreement among all shareholders — or among all shareholders together with one or more non-shareholders — may restrict, in whole or in part, the powers of the directors to manage or supervise the management of the corporation’s business and affairs.
A USA therefore can affect the corporation’s internal allocation of authority rather than merely create private contractual obligations between shareholders.
The Supreme Court of Canada emphasized this distinction in Duha Printers (Western) Ltd. v. Canada, describing a USA as a corporate-law hybrid that is partly contractual and partly constitutional in nature. The Court also treated a USA as part of the corporation’s constating framework because it can alter powers that would otherwise belong to the board.
For the position where no such agreement exists, see No Shareholder Agreement in Ontario: What Rights and Remedies Apply?.
Can a Sole Shareholder Create a Unanimous Shareholder Agreement?
Yes.
Under OBCA s. 108(3), where the registered holder of all issued shares makes a written declaration restricting, in whole or in part, the directors’ powers to manage or supervise the corporation, that declaration is deemed to be a unanimous shareholder agreement.
A USA can also continue to affect later shareholders. The OBCA contains provisions deeming persons who acquire shares subject to a USA to become parties to it in specified circumstances.
That statutory effect is another reason a USA should not be treated as merely an ordinary private contract.
What Happens When a USA Restricts Directors’ Powers?
The consequences can be significant.
Under OBCA s. 108(5), a shareholder who is a party to a USA assumes the rights, powers, duties, and liabilities of a director to the extent that the agreement restricts the directors’ discretion or powers. The directors are relieved of corresponding duties and liabilities to the same extent.
This can become important in litigation over:
- who had authority to make a particular corporate decision;
- whether shareholder approval was required;
- governance and management rights;
- responsibility for decisions made under transferred powers; and
- whether directors or shareholders complied with the USA.
For the underlying principles governing directors’ obligations, see Do Directors Owe Fiduciary Duties Directly to Shareholders in Ontario?.
Can a USA Provide a Procedure for Resolving Shareholder Disputes?
Yes.
OBCA s. 108(6) expressly provides that a USA may specify how it can be amended and may provide for disputes concerning the agreement to be referred to arbitration under procedures and conditions set out in the USA.
The precise language of the agreement therefore matters. A governance dispute may turn on whether the USA reserved a decision to the directors, transferred that power to shareholders, required a particular approval threshold, or imposed a contractual dispute-resolution process.
A breach of a USA may also interact with other shareholder remedies depending on the facts, including the oppression remedy.
How ME Law Approaches Unanimous Shareholder Agreement Disputes
ME Law begins by determining whether the document legally operates as a unanimous shareholder agreement and identifying the specific directors’ powers it restricts.
We then review the articles, by-laws, share structure, amendments, resolutions, corporate records, decision-making history, and relevant shareholder conduct to determine where the disputed power legally resided. This helps distinguish a contractual disagreement from a governance dispute involving statutory authority, director duties, shareholder liability, oppression, or other corporate remedies.
Contact ME Law to request a consultation.