Breaching an injunction can lead to civil contempt proceedings. Because an injunction is a court order rather than simply an agreement between the parties, non-compliance can expose the person in breach to court-imposed sanctions intended to enforce the order and protect the administration of justice.
A contempt finding is serious and is not automatic merely because one party alleges that an injunction was breached. The party seeking contempt must establish the required elements beyond a reasonable doubt.
What must be proved for civil contempt?
The Supreme Court of Canada set out the governing framework in Carey v. Laiken, 2015 SCC 17.
Civil contempt generally requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt that:
- the order alleged to have been breached stated clearly and unequivocally what the person was required to do or refrain from doing;
- the person alleged to be in contempt had actual knowledge of the order; and
- the person intentionally did the act prohibited by the order, or intentionally failed to do the act required by it.
The third requirement does not mean that the person must have intended to defy the court or interfere with the administration of justice. The relevant question is whether the act or omission itself was intentional and breached a clear order known to that person.
This is one reason the wording of an injunction matters. An order that is vague, uncertain, or overly broad can create significant enforcement problems.
For the broader role and structure of injunctive relief, see What is an injunction in Ontario?.
How is an injunction enforced through contempt proceedings?
Rule 60.11 of Ontario’s Rules of Civil Procedure governs contempt orders used to enforce an order requiring a person to do an act, other than payment of money, or to abstain from doing an act.
A contempt motion is brought before a judge in the proceeding in which the order was made. Rule 60.11 also contains specific procedural safeguards, including requirements concerning service of the contempt motion and the affidavit evidence used to support it.
Because contempt carries potentially serious consequences, the evidentiary record must establish precisely what the injunction required, what the alleged contemnor knew, and what conduct is said to have breached the order.
For more on injunction evidence generally, see What evidence matters most on an injunction motion in Ontario?.
What can the court do after finding contempt?
The court has substantial discretion under Rule 60.11.
Depending on the circumstances, the court may order the person in contempt to comply with the order, refrain from further prohibited conduct, pay a fine or costs, or comply with other terms considered necessary. In sufficiently serious cases, imprisonment is also available.
The appropriate response depends on matters such as the nature of the breach, its consequences, subsequent compliance, whether the breach can be remedied, and the circumstances surrounding the conduct.
A contempt motion should therefore not be treated simply as another ordinary procedural motion. The finding itself can have serious consequences, and the court retains discretion both in determining whether contempt should be found and in determining the appropriate sanction.
Can someone simply ignore an injunction while challenging it?
Generally, no.
A party who believes an injunction was wrongly granted, is too broad, or should no longer remain in effect should use the available court procedures to seek to vary, set aside, stay, or appeal the order, where the applicable procedural route permits it.
Until an order is changed or set aside, parties should not assume that disagreement with the order excuses non-compliance.
For the appellate context, see Can injunction orders be appealed in Ontario?.
How does ME Law approach an alleged breach of an injunction?
ME Law first examines the precise wording of the order, evidence of knowledge, the conduct alleged to constitute the breach, and whether the requirements for civil contempt can actually be established.
For parties seeking enforcement, the objective is to build a disciplined record showing exactly how the order was breached and what enforcement response is appropriate.
For parties accused of non-compliance, the analysis includes whether the order was sufficiently clear, whether the alleged conduct falls within its terms, whether the required knowledge and intentional conduct can be proved, and what procedural or remedial response is available.
For ME Law’s broader approach to obtaining and enforcing injunctive relief, see Injunctions.
Contact ME Law if you are seeking to enforce an injunction or responding to an allegation that an Ontario court order has been breached.