Shareholder dispute arbitration in Ontario may be required where the parties are bound by a valid arbitration agreement that covers the matter. Under s. 7(1) of the Arbitration Act, 1991, a court generally must stay covered court proceedings unless a statutory exception applies.
When Must a Shareholder Dispute Be Sent to Arbitration?
The first question is whether there is an arbitration agreement and whether the dispute falls within its scope.
An arbitration clause may appear in a shareholders’ agreement, unanimous shareholder agreement, or another agreement governing the parties’ relationship. OBCA s. 108(6) expressly permits a unanimous shareholder agreement to provide for unresolved matters pertaining to the agreement to be referred to arbitration.
See Unanimous Shareholder Agreement in Ontario: What Is It and Why Does It Matter?.
If a party nevertheless commences a court proceeding concerning a matter that the arbitration agreement requires to be arbitrated, s. 7(1) of the Arbitration Act generally requires the court, on another party’s motion, to stay the proceeding.
When Can the Court Refuse a Stay?
Section 7(2) identifies specific circumstances in which the court may refuse to stay the proceeding, including where:
- a party entered the arbitration agreement under a legal incapacity;
- the arbitration agreement is invalid;
- the subject matter cannot legally be arbitrated in Ontario;
- the stay motion was brought with undue delay; or
- the matter is appropriate for default or summary judgment.
The existence of a shareholder or oppression claim does not by itself determine the issue.
Ontario decisions demonstrate that an oppression claim may fall inside a sufficiently broad arbitration clause, while another oppression claim may remain outside arbitration where its substance does not fall within the particular agreement.
The language of the arbitration clause and the actual subject matter of the dispute therefore matter more than the label attached to the pleading.
What If Only Part of the Shareholder Dispute Is Covered by Arbitration?
Section 7(5) addresses proceedings containing both matters covered by an arbitration agreement and matters outside it.
Where the agreement covers only some matters and it is reasonable to separate them, the court may stay the arbitrable matters while allowing the other matters to continue.
In TELUS Communications Inc. v. Wellman, the Supreme Court of Canada confirmed that s. 7(5) does not give courts a general discretion to keep arbitrable matters in court merely because litigating everything together would be more convenient.
That distinction can be important where shareholder litigation combines contractual claims, oppression allegations, director-related claims, and other corporate remedies.
Can the Court Still Grant Urgent Relief if the Dispute Is Subject to Arbitration?
Potentially, yes.
Section 8(1) of the Arbitration Act preserves the court’s powers concerning the detention, preservation and inspection of property, interim injunctions, and the appointment of receivers to the same extent as in court proceedings.
An arbitration clause therefore does not necessarily prevent a party from seeking urgent court protection while the underlying dispute proceeds through arbitration.
See Urgent Shareholder Injunction in Ontario: Can It Stop a Corporate Step?.
How ME Law Approaches Shareholder Arbitration Disputes
ME Law begins by reviewing the arbitration clause, the agreements containing it, the parties bound by it, and the substance of each claim. We assess whether the dispute falls within the clause, whether a statutory exception to a stay is available, whether court and arbitration issues must be separated, and whether urgent interim relief is required.
Our Dispute Resolution practice addresses arbitration strategy alongside commercial and corporate litigation where the appropriate forum itself is contested.
Contact ME Law to request a consultation.